AmeriCommerce Review
Pros
-
- Reasonable monthly cost
- Easy to use
- Advanced features
- Intuitive design tools available
- Single page checkout
Cons
- Limited customer support hours
- Some outdated design templates
- Limited international selling features
AmeriCommerce Overview
Founded in 2005, AmeriCommerce began as an innovative shopping cart platform, the first to offer multiple store management, product embedding on other sites, and single page checkout. In 2014, Capital One took notice and acquired AmeriCommerce, bringing the platform under the Spark Pay umbrella. However, late last year, the tables turned once again. AmeriCommerce is no longer connected with Capital One and is back to being a business of its own.
Founded by Ed Stuffock, Charlie Cooper, and Stefan Barlow, AmeriCommerce has grown over the past twelve years to host over 5,000 sites. Collectively, AmeriCommerce sellers generate over half a billion dollars in transactions each year. Current clients include West Coast Shaving, Texas Beard Company, and Campbell’s.
Although AmeriCommerce has a significantly smaller customer base than most popular eCommerce platforms, it still makes waves in the eCommerce industry. The company has earned two notable recognitions. They won the CODiE Award for Best in Class eCommerce Software in 2010, and they were featured in Inc. Magazine’s 5000 list in 2012, 2013, and 2014.
Merchants choose AmeriCommerce for its intuitive admin, multiple store capabilities, and drag-and-drop theme editor. With AmeriCommerce, it’s easy to operate several sites from the same user-friendly admin. One word of caution: Because AmeriCommerce has limited international selling features and support hours, it’s really best for US merchants who plan on selling in the US. If you are based outside of the US or you plan on reaching international customers, you should consider another platform (you might take a look at Shopify or Magento).
Otherwise, keep reading to find out if AmeriCommerce has the features to fit your store’s needs.
Table of Contents
Pricing
AmeriCommerce offers five pricing tiers. All plans are billed monthly and have no setup or cancellation fees. You don’t need to sign a contract to get started with AmeriCommerce, and you won’t have to pay any transaction fees. Every plan includes customer support and a free shared SSL certificate.
If you’re just looking to try out AmeriCommerce, there is a free 14-day trial you can use to explore the platform and begin setting up a store. When you register for a trial, you’ll have to enter some personal information and a few details about your store, but you do not have to hand over a credit card number.
Here’s the pricing structure:
Steel: $24.95/month
- 100 Products
- 2 GB Bandwidth
- 250 MB Storage
Bronze: $39/month
- 500 Products
- 3 GB Bandwidth
- 1 GB Storage
Silver: $99/month
- 5,000 Products
- 15 GB Bandwidth
- 1 GB Storage
Gold: $149/month
- 10,000 Products
- 25 GB Bandwidth
- 2 GB Storage
Platinum: $299/month
- Unlimited Products
- 50 GB Bandwidth
- 5 GB Storage
Enterprise-level plans are also available.
AmeriCommerce’s multi-store functionality is one of its best features. You can build additional stores on any plan for just $39/month.
Keep in mind that while AmeriCommerce does not charge transaction fees, they do charge bandwidth overage fees, which range between $10/GB and $4/GB per month depending on your plan. Try to choose a plan that accurately fits your projected bandwidth usage. In addition, if you expect to go over your bandwidth allotment every month, but you don’t want to pay for a higher level plan, you can pre-purchase additional bandwidth. This extra bandwidth costs between $6/GB and $4/GB.
Web-Hosted Or Licensed
Web-hosted. AmeriCommerce outsources their web hosting to Rackspace; they boast a 99.9% uptime.
Hardware & Software Requirements
None. You only need a computer, a strong internet connection, and a current web browser.
Ease Of Use
AmeriCommerce offers a free 14-day trial, so you can test out the platform for yourself, no credit card required. You just need to enter some basic contact information and a bit of information about your business. You’ll be automatically directed to the admin panel of your new store.
Once there, a setup wizard will guide you through entering a store name, choosing a theme, and adding your first product (not to worry, you can change everything later). A screen overlay with pop-up bubbles shows how to find a few features that might not be obvious at first. I think AmeriCommerce could do a better job with its beginners tutorial, but fortunately, for the most part, the platform isn’t too difficult to figure out by yourself.
I started the process by adding a few products of my own. Adding products is a two-step process. You first have to add the product to your catalog. Then, you can create the full range of product, shipping, and tax details.
AmeriCommerce has filed away their more advanced features under “Power Features.” To access those features, you must click to activate them, though it doesn’t cost extra to use them. The Power Features are only listed in a separate category because AmeriCommerce presumably doesn’t want to overwhelm new users with too many features.
Overall, I found AmeriCommerce’s dashboard reasonably easy to learn. If you need a little extra help, there’s a Knowledge Base and a few video tutorials available to get you moving.
Features
AmeriCommerce has enough features to meet the needs of most merchants. More advanced functionality is available in the form of Power Features and add-ons. The following are a few of the features I deem most important. Head over to the AmeriCommerce website for the full feature list.
Store Management
- Multiple Storefronts: This is, without a doubt, AmeriCommerce’s most attractive feature. AmeriCommerce lets you operate multiple stores from the same admin.
- Automatic Shipping Rates: Calculate shipping rates from major carriers like UPS, USPS, and FedEx.
- Dropshipping: Manage orders with products from multiple dropshippers. Send email notifications to fulfillment warehouses.
- Taxes Calculator: Calculate taxes accurately and automatically.
- User Roles: Assign your employees different logins and permissions.
- Bulk Import: Make migration a little easier.
Products
- Buy Buttons: Embed buy buttons in your blogs, Facebook page, and other social media sites.
- Unlimited Variables: List an unlimited number of sizes, colors, styles and other features that your products may have.
- Digital Products: Sell both physical and digital products on the same site.
- Inventory Management: Track your inventory, including different product options and variants.
- Product Videos: Let customers see your products from all sides (but keep in mind that product videos use a lot of bandwidth and can slow down your site).
- Enable Product Reviews: Find out what your customer like and don’t like about your products and inspire confidence in other shoppers.
- Wish Lists: Allow customers to return to the items they’re considering.
Orders & Shopping
- Top Sellers, Suggested Items & Related Items: Take advantage of cross-sells and up-sells.
- Phone Orders: Accept orders via the phone. You can create orders easily from the admin.
- Built-In Payment Types: Accept partial payment, split payments, gift cards, and customer loyalty points.
- Customer Accounts & Guest Checkout: Customers who aren’t ready to commit to your brand yet can still purchase from you.
Marketing & SEO
- Email Automation: Automate your email marketing campaign and send drip series emails.
- SEO Tools: Utilize permalinks, page titles, H1, meta tags, alt tags, and an auto-generated sitemap.xml.
- Blogs: Build your brand, increase SEO, and increase organic traffic through consistent blogging.
- Social Media Integration: Link your store to Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, and Instagram.
Reports
- Google Analytics: Integrate with Google’s free software.
- Traffic & Referral Reports: Find out where your customers are coming from.
- PPC Keyword Reporting: Discover the keywords you aren’t bidding on yet.
- Abandoned Cart Reports: Find out more about customers who don’t purchase.
B2B Features
- Customer Type Pricing: List different prices for different types of customers.
- Smart Shipping: Calculate rates based on sending and receiving warehouse locations.
- Multiple Stores: Create multiple sites to separate your retail and wholesale sales.
- Customer-Specific Payment Methods: Allow approved wholesale customers to pay with checks, POs, etc.
- Hide Pricing: Require customers to log in to view pricing, checkout, and their shopping cart.
AmeriCommerce’s feature set is not the most expansive, but it is complete. Most merchants will find they have nearly all the features they need out-of-the-box. And, like I mentioned above, features that don’t come built-in can always be added on as integrations.
Web Design
AmeriCommerce’s collection of free, pre-made themes includes 63 options. Of these themes, only about half are fully mobile responsive.
As far as looks go, AmeriCommerce’s themes are hit and miss. There are a few truly stunning designs…
Unfortunately, not all of the themes are this elegant. About half of AmeriCommerce’s options already look fairly dated (the theme below, for example)…
Furthermore, AmeriCommerce’s selection is fairly slim in terms of diversity. A few themes are just variations of the same design in different colors.
Fortunately, there are several theme editors you can use to customize your site. There are WYSIWYG editors and a drag-and-drop editor available for your storefront. For those a little more tech savvy, there are HTML and CSS editors in the backend.
If you do decide to go the custom theme route (or you just want to tweak a pre-made theme), AmeriCommerce has design services available for a price.
(Quick tip: No matter what, choose a responsive theme. These days, 58% of all online browsing is done on a mobile device. You don’t want to miss out on that traffic.)
Integrations & Add-Ons
AmeriCommerce’s app store is on the smaller side, with 61 available integrations. You can expect to find common integrations there, most of which are available at “third-party pricing.” Here are a few of my favorite integrations:
- Constant Contact: Email marketing. 3rd Party Pricing.
- 71 lbs: Automated Shipping Refunds. 3rd Party Pricing.
- Avalara AvaTax: Automatic tax calculation. 3rd Party Pricing.
- AmeriSync QuickBooks Order Sync: Accounting software. $300.
- MailChimp: Email marketing. 3rd Party Pricing.
There’s also a REST API available, so you can hire developers to create a connection to any app you choose.
Payment Processing
AmeriCommerce stores integrate with about 50 payment gateways. This list includes the most popular payment gateways, such as:
Additionally, AmeriCommerce offers their own Merchant Services payment option.
Customer Service & Technical Support
AmeriCommerce’s customer service is reportedly good when it’s available. Phone hours are limited to M-F 8 AM–6 PM CST and Sat 9 AM–5 PM. This makes getting live customer support a challenge, especially for merchants in different time zones.
Here’s how you can access AmeriCommerce’s support:
- AmeriCommerce Support: Requires login.
- Video Tutorials
- Blog
- Resources: Articles, ebooks, videos, and guides.
- Contact Portal: Recommended for general questions, sales, and non-urgent technical inquiries.
- Knowledge Center
Negative Reviews & Complaints
There aren’t very many customer reviews online about AmeriCommerce’s shopping cart. In general, AmeriCommerce customers are satisfied with their online platform, but they do have a few complaints. Negative comments tend to address:
- Poor Customer Support: AmeriCommerce’s limited support hours are customers’ number one frustration. As one customer on Facebook pointed out, “The internet doesn’t stop.” AmeriCommerce support, however, does. Customers also mention delayed responses to their inquiries.
- Lack Of International Payment Options: AmeriCommerce works best for US merchants who plan on selling in the US. Nevertheless, there are a few international payment gateways available: eWay, BeanStream, PSIGate XML interface, and PayPal.
- Extra Fees: If you don’t choose a plan that can handle your store’s bandwidth usage, you can expect some bandwidth overage fees. Some customers feel they’re being nickeled and dimed.
- Lack Of Variety In Themes: I agree with this particular gripe. AmeriCommerce could really step it up a notch with their web design. We’ve seen that they can create elegant web design, now we’re just waiting for more of those options.
Positive Reviews & Testimonials
Here’s what AmeriCommerce customers like most about their platform.
- Multiple Store Management: This is what everyone loves most. You can manage dozens of stores from the same admin.
- Dependable: AmeriCommerce is hosted by Rackspace, which boasts a reliable uptime record. In addition, they’ll update your software regularly so everything keeps running smoothly.
- Customizable: Using AmeriCommerce’s “Power Features” you can easily adjust your dashboard to be as simple or as robust as you’d like.
- Buy Buttons: Sell your products directly on your business’s Facebook page or blog.
Customers also list AmeriCommerce’s pricing, quick setup, and expansive features as reasons to choose the platform.
Security
AmeriCommerce is PCI compliant and offers each merchant a free 128-bit shared SSL certificate. In order to benefit from that shared SSL, you’ll have to use AmeriCommerce’s subdomain for checkout (yourstorename.americommerce.com). If you’d prefer to have your checkout page on your own domain, you’ll have to buy your own SSL certificate.
Additionally, AmeriCommerce’s servers use enterprise quality Cisco firewalls. AmeriCommerce also offers DDoS mitigation services through Rackspace, and the software is reviewed every day by AlertLogic to monitor for potential vulnerabilities.
Final Verdict
I don’t have a particularly strong opinion of AmeriCommerce, either positive or negative. It isn’t the most exciting eCommerce platform I’ve ever seen, nor is it the worst. AmeriCommerce seems to cover all of the bases required for a user-friendly shopping cart and manages to offer a few additional features as well. The software’s most attractive feature is certainly the ability to operate multiple sites from the same admin–the low cost of each additional store is equally attractive.
That isn’t to say that AmeriCommerce is without fault. This cart is by Americans and for Americans, so if you’re looking to sell internationally, AmeriCommerce is not the best route. You should also be wary of the company’s limited customer service hours. If you aren’t comfortable handling problems on your own, you might consider looking elsewhere.
Whatever the case, I always recommend that you try out the platform before you commit. Sign up for a free trial, test the customer service, and see if AmeriCommerce can fit your business’s needs.
The Merchant Maverick Seal of Approval 🏆
AmeriCommerce ![]() |
---|
After hours of in-depth research and evaluation, we can confidently recommend this brand to our readers. Get started today and see AmeriCommerce for yourself.
The Merchant Maverick Seal of Approval 🏆
AmeriCommerce ![]() |
---|
After hours of in-depth research and evaluation, we can confidently recommend this brand to our readers. Get started today and see AmeriCommerce for yourself.
Organization Name: para fragrance
I have been using Americommerce since 2014 So far it has been very good. The pros include: + Excellent uptime+ Responsive to support tickets and questions+ very Easy to use . Thank you
We were with Americart for our shopping cart for many years and were very happy with the product and support team. The cart integrated seamlessly with our ecommerce site and was user-friendly to navigate and use, particularly since we are a mom and pop site without extensive IT experience and support. When SparkPay took over, we ran into several problems, mainly with getting the same shipping options to work with our site. However, the main problem was and remains the inability to have a drop-down list indicating whether UPS shipments are to a commercial or residential address (we were told by SparkPay that we had to choose one or the other, which is ludricrous; any ecommerce site that ships to both residential and business customers would agree with that); at a later date, we received an email saying that to have that shipping choice available on our site, it would cost extra. Also, we recently had a complaint from one of our business customers that at least twice she had a problem with getting the cart to accept an address she wanted a product shipped to. As she pointed out, if she is having a problem, there are probably other customers having the same problem, and we may be losing business because of it.We were very happy with Americart and wish it were still available. Unless the above issues are not satisfactorily corrected by SparkPay in the near future, it is highly likely that we will seek a new shopping cart provider.
This comment refers to an earlier version of this review and may be outdated.
I have a fix that I use, to solve the Residential/Commercial issue. Yes, stupid that this simple offering isn’t a standard option.
Simply create a Fedex account online, and use that information. So, you have your regular UPS Ground (rename it UPS Ground Residential) and also use Fedex Home Delivery (rename it UPS Ground Commercial, and set-up with the Fedex account info that you received).
You’ll need to of course find the right modification for this Fedex Home Delivery rate (since it’s not the actual commercial rate), so that it somewhat matches your UPS Ground Commercial Rates (I’ve found a -33% reduction, from this Fedex Home Delivery online rate, works pretty close for me).
Be sure you modify the Fedex Home Delivery rate, and make that shipping option visible, as when I did this, what initially threw me, was that some of the other Fedex options, even though should have been visible, didn’t work/show in the cart.
Hope that helps.
This comment refers to an earlier version of this review and may be outdated.
I moved from Bigcommerce to Sparkpay at the beginning of the year. So far it has been a positive experience and the best fit for my high volume business. Support has been very helpful to me so perhaps that has improved since the previous comments were left, but for me it has been much better than what I received with BC. There was a bit of a leaning curve going to this platform but in the long run their greater number of tools and functions should be a good value. There are a few really good platforms out there and for our needs Sparkpay fit the bill better than others. Sparkpay is also striving at helping those migrating (fleeing) Bigcommerce after BC raised rates 500%. I appreciated the built-in import tools designed to move my site content, orders, and customers. There were times I got stuck or needed help and their support came through for me. Granted they are only available Monday-Friday for general support but that wasn’t a big deal to me, compared to Bigcommerce who would routinely ignore requests. Overall I give Spark Pay 4.5 stars. No platform is perfect but this one so far has been stepping up to the plate for my company.
This comment refers to an earlier version of this review and may be outdated.
Just an update after using this platform for a few months. So far it has been very good. The pros include: + Excellent uptime+ Responsive to support tickets and questions+ Easy to use once you get use to their UICons:- Buggy interface with shipping provider (ShipStation) when dealing with multiple microstores, but they are working on this. – Bandwidth issues (more about this below)- Lack of any user community to share tips or suggestions. They have a forum but few post and almost no one replies, so its a virtual ghost town. fIn regards to the bandwidth issue, this is something that can catch you off guard if not careful. I thought I was doing pretty good when suddenly my monthly totals spiked and I ended up with a small bandwidth overage charge. Turns out that some out of control spiders and crawlers were eating up bandwidth by scanning every image and page on an hourly basis. SparkPay does not filter or restrict any of these so it is up to you to monitor and block them. Luckily they have a tool to block by the IP or user agent, but some still find their way in. One such bandwidth abuser was Alltop.com (user agent Alltop/1) who is a site that is nothing more than an article farm of scanned content pulled from blogs and sites. They blatantly ignore your Robots.txt file directives so don’t even bother with that. I had to file a complaint with their host to finally rid them of the scans which were hammering my site every few minutes. Other offenders include the Chinese and Russian bots that had to be blocked, and I still find new ones once a week. My store falls into a slot where the Silver plan is more than enough of everything except the bandwidth which I border on every month. Overall, good platform for those wanting something all inclusive, or all of those who had to flee BigCommerce after they showed such disrespect for small/mid sized businesses.
This comment refers to an earlier version of this review and may be outdated.
Bandwidth billing is deceptive.I started with the lowest plan. After a few months I started getting billed for extra bandwidth each month. (The billing is very sneaky. They won’t tell you how much bandwidth you used, but just bill you $40) So, I switched to a higher bandwidth plan because it’s less expensive to pay for bandwidth up front. Now I had more bandwidth then I had ever used before. The very next month? More bandwidth charges! Mysteriously, my bandwidth use had doubled in the next month even though my page views for those 2 months were only up slightly.My site hasn’t changed at all in this time. Zero edits.I have the same traffic patterns among pages.Over 8 months, my page views have doubled, but for some reason I’m paying for 4x the bandwidth.
This comment refers to an earlier version of this review and may be outdated.
While you have done a good job of describing the features that AmeriCommerce offers, I don’t think you have given sufficient weight to the EXTREMELY POOR SUPPORT. I spent 10 months waiting for them to port a shopping cart over from AmeriCart. Communication from them was non-existent. Promises were made that were never kept. That client eventually gave up and went with a different solution. Now I’m on hold again with my very last AmeriCommerce client. The shopping cart isn’t working correctly because of a screw up on their part and its been a week and with feedback. If you have months to wait, you may eventually get something done. I don’t have that kind of time.
This comment refers to an earlier version of this review and may be outdated.
Haven’t seen an updated review, am I missing it somewhere? Would like to know what the verdict is in 2015 🙂
This comment refers to an earlier version of this review and may be outdated.
Stephanie,
The review has been updated. Thanks for the inquiry!
This comment refers to an earlier version of this review and may be outdated.
I’ve been using Americommerce since 2008 and have seen it constantly being enhanced throughout the years. I’ve been beta testing the new admin and comparing it to the previous 2 iterations, I can honestly say it is “amazing”. The time to perform administrative tasks in the admin is reduced significantly by virtue of the new ‘flow’ as well as the speed in which the new interface loads.I agree with your statements about the included free themes which may be an initial setback, however they offer a solid foundation to further customize/refine instead of starting from scratch.Hopefully we will see some premium themes offered in the future.
This comment refers to an earlier version of this review and may be outdated.
Hi Amad and Merchant Maverick team,
Thanks for such a complete and thoughtful review of AmeriCommerce. I think you did an excellent job touching on all the points (both good and bad) and you’re readers should find it helpful.
I thought I’d offer a few points of feedback and clarity.
– Authorize.net is indeed a partner but we also have our own AmeriCommerce Merchant Services which is less expensive and typically a good fit for many of our merchants. We support more than 50 payment gateways so it’s not usually an issue supporting the processor of your choice. And, I think your site offers tons of helpful information on merchants.
– You’re right, our Admin can be hard on the eyes and some people have found it confusing since we offer a lot of tools and settings for multiplestores and advanced options (unlike shopify and others).
– The Admin is being redesigned for a better and more intuitive user experience. It is NOT hard on the eyes and much easier to move around. Plus it’s designed to be responsive for tablets and mobile devices. The new admin will be available by Summer 2013.
– Our themes are dated and utilitarian in nature. Historically, we have always attracted power users, mature internet retailers which tend to have the resources and budget to theme their sites with a custom look and feel. This is an area we want to address with more themes. We offer affordable custom web design too, but understand it’s helpful to have more theme options than we currently do.
– Customer Service. What can I say here… Yes. We’ve got to increase our window of availability for international users and even weekend warriors trying to work on their sites during non-business hours. All I can say is that we thank all our customers for their patience as we are growing and continuing to improve. Extended hours and weekend support is coming and we are continually improving our support systems and response times. We are very serious about improving the customer experience with our company and expect to see big changes here over time.
For what it’s worth, I must admit we tend to be an awesome fit for mature retailers who have specific needs and are already online. We help a lot of people re-platform to us from the smaller simple stores because they end up needing advanced capabilities and tooling they just didn’t know they needed when they first started. This does put completely new store owners at a disadvantage and we hope to be able to improve their experience to get started selling online.
Thanks again for your review of AmeriCommerce.
And awesome job managing this site – it’s a great service to people trying to navigate how ecommerce works and get helpful and honest feedback.
Cheers!
Justin McCullough
AmeriCommerce
@mccJustin
This comment refers to an earlier version of this review and may be outdated.
Justin,
Thank you for the kind words and the extra details about AmeriCommerce.
We were hesitant about publishing the review initially because we knew that you’re planning on rolling out a new version of AmeriCommerce in the Summer.
We ultimately decided to run with it, but we’re definitely keeping an eye out for the new software. Once it’s live, we’ll revisit AmeriCommerce and update the review accordingly.
Thanks again Justin. Best of luck to you and AmeriCommerce. Let’s keep in touch.
-Amad
This comment refers to an earlier version of this review and may be outdated.