Square vs. PayPal Here

• 46 comments
• Posted on: May 18, 2017
• Posted by: Melissa Johnson

The mobile payments space has undergone a major transformation in the past few years. Small contenders have come and gone, new names have emerged. But it feels like the big names — such as Square and PayPal Here — have gotten bigger.

Square (see our review) has been a giant in the mobile payment processing since its inception in 2009. Claiming an estimated 2 million merchants, Square has made it possible for anyone to accept credit card payments and grow their business with a dazzling and ever-growing suite of tools and apps. PayPal is a behemoth in all forms of commerce, and it’s dominated the online payments space in particular, with about 8 million PayPal for Business users. In 2012, it ventured into mobile payments with the PayPal Here app (see our review), which works with the rest of the PayPal Suite.

When you compare Square vs PayPal Here, you’ll see that have a hefty share of the mobile payment market and instant recognizability for consumers. They also have many similar offerings. To make a potentially long story short, Square has earned a 4.5-star rating for the sheer value it provides, while PayPal has earned a respectable 4 stars. However, depending on what capabilities you need, either could be a great choice.

Stick around while I briefly breakdown the differences between the two mPOS apps. For a more in-depth look at each, check out our full reviews of Square and PayPal Here!

Products and Services:

Winner: Square

Square and PayPal Here are both mobile Point of Sale (mPOS) services, requiring just a cell phone or tablet to accept credit cards. They’re great for merchants at conventions and trade shows, street vendors, repair businesses, professional services, restaurants and retail boutiques… Basically anywhere that you may not have an actual register, or don’t need a large, complicated POS system, either service will give you what you need.

As far as core features are concerned, you’re going to get the same experience from both. That includes:

• Accept all forms of credit
• Keyed transaction support
• Record cash transactions
• Issue full and partial refunds
• Apply Discounts
• Item library with product descriptions, images, and variants
• Barcodes and SKUs
• Receipt printing
• Receipts via email/SMS
• Cash drawer support
• Invoicing

That said, Square’s app is very nearly a full-fledged POS, and it offers several additional services free of charge — inventory management with counts and low-stock alerts and a virtual terminal for example. You can add services such as employee management and customer loyalty, to. Not only that, but everything synchronizes seamlessly in the Square Dashboard. If you want the freedom to create a register setup and use the same app for your mobile sales, you can do that with Square almost effortlessly.

There’s just one shortcoming: Square has put a lot of effort into its eCommerce offerings of late, but it’s still not the most robust option out there. If your online sales are as important to you as your mobile sales, PayPal might be the better option for you.

If you want add-ons, PayPal Here isn’t nearly as robust as Square. Its inventory features are more limited (there’s no count except with an add-on service). and most notably, PayPal Here’s item library doesn’t sync with the rest of your PayPal setup. There’s no offline mode, a fact that continues to dismay me.

However, Paypal’s eCommerce capabilities are easily the best on the market. If selling online as well as on mobile devices is a priority for you, you shouldn’t overlook the value and compatibility PayPal offers.

In the end, if you’re just looking at mobile, I think these solutions are pretty well matched, but Square can do just a bit more, and that’s why it ultimately comes out on top. If you want to take either solution to a counter top, Square still offers more functionality — but if you’re selling online as well, PayPal has a distinct advantage. I think it’s important when choosing an mPOS you look at your technical needs as well as how the app of your choosing fits into the rest of your business. Omni-channel solutions are becoming far more common and they can be a very effective way to manage payment processing and orders across all these different channels.

Compatible Hardware:

Winner: Square

For a mobile setup, really, all you need is a compatible smartphone or tablet and a credit card reader. You can send your customers digital receipts from either PayPal Here or Square. But if you want a full-fledged register, you can have that, too — that means receipt printer, cash drawer, the whole shebang.

Supported Phones and Tablets: 

Both PayPal Here and Square are designed to work on Android and iOS devices — tablets and smartphones. However, you’ll get maximum capabilities out of Square if you’re running an iPad. On the other hand, PayPal Here supports a small assortment of Windows devices as well. You’ve got a fairly large list of supported devices on both, and few compatibility issues on either part.

Supported Card Readers:

You can still get a free magstripe reader from PayPal Here and Square for signing up. However, at this point it’s very prudent for you to get an EMV (chip card) reader. They aren’t free, but it will remove a huge liability from your business.

PayPal’s only other carder reader option, its EMV reader, is my favorite device on the market right now: The Miura M010. It’s a Bluetooth-enabled all-in-one reader (meaning it supports EMV, NFC/contactless and magstripe). Not only that but it’s fairly comfortable to hold in your hand. you can even get a cradle with built in charger for a countertop setup. Check out all the reasons I like it in my unboxing review.

Square has a larger assortment of devices to choose from. There’s a headphone jack EMV/magstripe reader as well as its Contactless + Chip Card reader, which supports NFC and EMV but not magstripe transactions. It also has a dock but it isn’t exactly friendly to handheld use. You can also get the Miura M010 for Square. however, whereas PayPal’s version supports both Android and iOS, Square’s only works with iOS. See how Square’s hardware stacks up against other options.

As far as price, that’ll be something you’ll have to decide for yourself. PayPal’s reader retails for $79.99, while Square offers it’s contactless + chip card reader for $49.

As I’ve already said, I definitely prefer the Miura M010. I think it has a better design and is more versatile. But Square wins out in this category simply because it has a larger array of options at more cost-effective price points.

Other Supported Hardware:

PayPal Here and Square both accommodate a variety of receipt printers, cash drawers, even barcode scanners. And depending on what you need, you can get a pre-assembled bundle of hardware directly through Square or through POS Portal for PayPal Here. You’ll save over buying each item individually, but prices vary depending on what equipment you want. There’s no doubt in my mind that Square has the better assortment — but do you need one? If you just need mobile processing, probably not. A smart device and a card reader will be more than sufficient.

In all, I appreciate the beauty of PayPal’s simplicity, whereas you might find yourself bewildered over the Square options, but the more affordable hardware and greater selection of pre-designed bundles are nice.

Fees and Rates:

Winner: Tie

While the cost of hardware is notably different, Square and PayPal Here do offer similar prices for credit card processing. Neither service charges any regular fees beyond those incurred per transaction, though with both you can opt for add-on services. If you’re just running the app and maybe eCommerce, you might save a tiny tiny fraction with PayPal Here, but 0.05% is a very tiny amount at this scale, and you should consider other factors.

Here’s what you’ll pay:

That’s some pretty fair pricing, and the lack of a per-transaction fee for swipes makes it favorable to low-volume businesses.

If you want more from your mPOS, here are some additional options:

PayPal:

• Hosted Payment Page and Virtual Terminal: $30/month
• Recurring Billing: $10/month
• Advanced inventory through Shopventory: $25/month

Square:

• Appointment Booking: Starting at $30/month
• Loyalty: $25/month/location
• Virtual Terminal: No monthly fee
• Recurring Billing/Card on File: 3.5% + $0.15 per transaction
• Advanced Inventory through Shopventory: $25/month

The main advantage to PayPal is how quickly your money is available: Any mobile payments you accept are available almost instantly in your PayPal account. That means if you have the PayPal debit card, you can spend your money right away.

Square sends its payments to your bank account within 1-2 business days, depending on when the payment was processed. Payments taken before 5 p.m. Pacific time are available the next business day; payments made after 5 p.m. Pacific time are available the second business day. However, you can also initiate an Instant Deposit for 1% of the transferred sum.

However, if you don’t have the PayPal debit card, or you prefer to route all your funds to your bank account, Square has the advantage. An ACH transfer from PayPal to your bank will take 3-4 days, which could be an issue for some merchants.

I honestly feel like this is a draw, especially if you’re only interested in the mPOS.

Their pricing for their core features — the mPOS and eCommerce suites — are virtually identical. And of course, let’s not overlook how fast you have access to your funds — with PayPal it’s almost instant. You can get your funds right away with Square for a slight fee. But recurring billing or a virtual terminal will cost you significantly more with PayPal. That marginally lower rate won’t actually save you money until you start processing $10k in just virtual terminal transactions.

As always, we encourage you to do the math yourself based on your own processing history and business needs. That is the only way to see whether the costs are justifiable.

Contract Length and Early Termination Fee:

Winner: Tie

One of the advantages to both Square and PayPal Here is that there’s no contract, no monthly fees, no termination fees. If you don’t like the service, just stop using it and find another one. You can’t get a better deal than that.

Sales and Advertising Transparency:

Winner: Tie

In general, both Square and PayPal Here deliver what they offer: an effective mobile payment solution with up-front pricing and no hidden fees.

That said, both services could be spell out some policies out more clearly, a topic we touched on in our reviews of Square and PayPal Here. The holds are a point of contention for merchants, who understandably want their money as soon as possible. There are no started limits, though it seems larger than average transactions can trigger reviews of an account.

You’ll find both PayPal and Square have active social media and social media support channels too. I would expect no less from these two companies. But I think Square is putting out a lot more content to help merchants get the most from their Square accounts.

Customer Service and Technical Support:

Winner: Tie

Neither Square nor PayPal is going to be winning any major awards for the quality of its customer support. In fact, both can be quite spotty, much to the dismay of merchants. I think Square has invested a lot lately in its customer support channels and improving the overall quality. PayPal, meanwhile, focuses on being more flexible and supportive of merchants. But there’s one rather large disadvantage in choosing either company, which we’ll get to.

Square support options include:

• Help Center: Very thorough and detailed, covering just about any topic you might need. If you’re having trouble setting up or using your Square account, start here and all your questions should be answered.
• Social Media: Square’s support Twitter feed (@SqSupport) is active (though not as active as PayPal’s), and its YouTube channel is full of instructional videos. Square even allows you to post directly to its Facebook page, something it previously hadn’t allowed.
• Contact Us Form: A mainstay of help desks everywhere.
• Phone Support: The biggest flaw in Square’s phone support is that it’s only available if you have a code, which some people have reported having trouble getting. If your account is terminated, you lose all access to phone support.
• Seller Community Forum: Get advice from other Square users as well as from Square staff on this growing forum.

PayPal Here support goes through the main PayPal system. Again, you can pick the option that suits your needs:

• PayPal Hub Home: Start here to get all your questions answered. The help center is organized by topic, with FAQs you may have.
• PayPal Community Forum: Get answers from other PayPal users.
• Social Media: Facebook and Twitter. Specifically, tweet @AskPayPal Monday-Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. central time, and they’ll go find you an answer.
• Phone and Email: The online consensus about PayPal’s phone support seems to be that the service is inconsistent at best. Fortunately, most of the answers you need are available through the help desk, community forum, or social media.

Both have a lot of options for support. For most technical questions (“how do I…”), you should be able to use the self-help or community options and get an answer. However, the problems usually start to arise when a merchant encounters a hold.

Both companies will typically request a variety of documents relating to your business and/or a specific transaction. You don’t have many options except to comply and provide as much information as you can to verify your processing history and transactions. Sometimes you can get the matter cleared up quickly — PayPal seems to be more forgiving in this regard.

And then of course there’s the worst-case scenario: an account termination. Unfortunately, there’s not much you can do if this happens to you. Both companies’ user agreements say they can terminate an account at any time with no justification.

Most complaints about Square and its customer service actually stem from account terminations. When it happens, Square shuts merchants out of the phone support system, which is an endless source of frustration, to be sure. You’ll get an email, with no reasoning and no chance of appeal. Complaints about quality of service for active merchants who have questions are getting to be less common.

PayPal’s complaints are a bit more of a mixed bag, but spotty phone service is a key issue. Some sales reps can help. Others can’t. It does not appear that PayPal locks merchants out of phone support after a termination, though I also haven’t seen proof that calling can help get your account reinstated, either. But if you need assistance and everything else fails, you can usually get help through the BBB, which well get into in the next section.

It’s tough to call a clear winner here because each has different strengths. However, you should take heart in knowing you can get clear and fast answers to most technical issues from either company, usually without ever having to talk to anyone.

Speaking of complaints, however…

Negative Reviews and Complaints:

Winner: PayPal Here

Complaints are never a good thing, but they happen. Sorting through the mess of complaints for Square and PayPal Here can be daunting. Normally we’d consult the BBB, but all complaints about PayPal Here are routed through PayPal’s main page (which has some 6,000+ complaints), which makes it a little bit challenging. Sites like RipOffReport are also full of people who have been scammed by merchants on Square or PayPal and want the companies to do something about it. (They typically won’t.)

In short, that means drawing direct, apples-to-apples comparisons about complaint volume is difficult (not to mention that we don’t have the exact size of each service’s user base.) But we can use these comments other ones around the web to get a picture of where the problems and pain points lie.

The biggest issue with both Square and PayPal Here is simply account stability. These are third-party processors, which means they aggregate accounts instead of giving you a merchant account of your own. There’s an inherent level of risk. Neither company is immune to the fallout that stems from this practice. But does one company offer greater stability than the other? Honestly, I don’t see any compelling evidence either way. I’m going to call it a draw in that regard.

If you do encounter the dreaded hold or account termination, you can expect to get your money sometime within 90 to 180 days. While that wait can be a nightmare, it’s also industry standard. Again, neither company appears to be more reliable than the other in this regard, and you’re not going to get anything better from any other companies out there. Processing companies hold these funds so they don’t find themselves out a large sum of money if a bunch of unhappy customers start filing chargebacks against a merchant whose account has been closed.

So neither account is guaranteed to be 100% stable. If you have irregular but large transactions or run a business in a high-risk industry, you probably want to think twice about using either of these services. That includes selling auctions and antiques, and even some branches of professional services. Instead, get a merchant account with a mobile option. Or open an account with Square and another with PayPal and keep one around as a backup option.

We’ve already talked about PayPal and Square and what happens when your account gets terminated. And here is where BBB complaints do start to come in handy. While there’s a lot of junk complaints to sort through, you can also tell how each company responds to issues.

And here’s probably my favorite thing about PayPal: BBB complaints are handled by the Office of Executive Escalations. And they’re pretty darn good at what they do. You can get helpful answers and a lot of the time PayPal will work with you to solve the problem. I’ve seen accounts reinstated and holds lifted. You might not get everything you wanted, but this stands in stark comparison to Square’s approach, which is to shut you out and give you templated responses with no real answers.

Positive Reviews and Testimonials:

Winner: Tie

You’re going to find some pretty solid supporters on both sides of the Square vs PayPal Here debate. Both apps are well designed and easy to use, with good reviews for the most part. They both make mobile payments available to people who might otherwise not be able to manage them. The apps are simple to use and compatible with a large assortment of phones and tablets.

People seem to like how affordable Square’s hardware is, and it’s hard to argue with the sheer value Square offers if you plan to use all of its features.

PayPal Here tends to draw people in because of the online sales capabilities and the centralization with the PayPal platform.

PayPal has some video testimonials on its YouTube channel. Square has even more.

What freaks a lot of people out when they start digging into either company is the large number of complaints from people who had their accounts terminated for no apparent reason. But at the same time, plenty of people use both Square and PayPal Here with no problem. They just tend to be a bit less vocal. We have some satisfied customers for both PayPal Here and Square who have posted on our reviews, and there’s good news scattered elsewhere, too.

The sheer number of disgruntled customers can seem scary, but you have to bear in mind that’s actually the minority of users. If either company were losing more customers than it gained, it wouldn’t stay afloat very long. So I encourage you, if you’ve decided that an mPOS is the best option, to focus on the good stuff (the features, being able to take cards virtually anywhere). Just be aware of the risks of using a third-party processor.

Final Verdict:

Winner: Square

In the Square vs PayPal Here debate, honestly believe that both Square and PayPal Here are excellent mPOS options — without question among the best out there. They have comparable pricing, similar feature sets, and virtually identical contract terms and customer support options. Neither one is inherently more stable than the other.

If you need a LOT of features and you want to create a seamless mPOS/countertop experience, Square is the clear winner. PayPal Here lags behind Square as far as features and overall value add go. But you’re only going to benefit if you actually plan to use all those extra POS-based features, like the offline mode or virtual terminal.

If you want strong Ccommerce support to go with your mPOS, PayPal is the better option. You’ll find a lot more shopping cart and software integrations. And of course, you can integrate PayPal into a lot more full-fledged POS options to go with the PayPal Here mPOS.

So yes, Square is the ultimate winner. But it’s definitely a close race and some merchants will be better served by PayPal Here — or at least, they’ll get as much value and use out of it. If you are still on the fence about which option to choose, I recommend making a list of all the features you need and what you prioritize in an mPOS. How do you want your business to grow? Which facets of the business are most important. Once you’ve identified what you need, making the decision will be a lot easier.

Want to learn more about Square vs PayPal Here? Check out our reviews of both products or give these services a try. We’d love to hear from you, too, so if you have any questions feel free to contact us!

• Bio
• Latest Posts

Melissa Johnson

Melissa Johnson is an independent writer and editor who loves e-commerce, digital marketing, technology, and social media. Once upon a time, she earned a journalism degree, but she went on to discover that she could work from home, researching, editing, and writing about the things she found most interesting. When she's not tied to her laptop, Melissa can usually be found in the kitchen, reading a book, or doing something of the nerdy persuasion.

Latest posts by Melissa Johnson (see all)

• Merchant’s Guide to Preventing Card-Present Fraud - October 18, 2017
• Square vs. SumUp - September 8, 2017
• How to Avoid Merchant Account Holds, Freezes, and Terminations - September 4, 2017
• The Complete Guide to American Express Interchange Fees and Processing Rates - August 31, 2017
• How Much Does Square Charge? - August 11, 2017

46 Comments

Nette October 12, 2017 at 4:06 pm

Melissa,
Thanks very much for sharing your time and insights!
Divine Blessings,
Linette

Reply
Jimmy October 11, 2017 at 8:55 am

I had a Square but terrible customer support. After using Square for a year it one day would not allow me to log on. Said email address was wrong. Tried contacting customer support but support is not available without email address, which I had not changed but Square did not recognize. Tried ordering replacement but got message that my email was already linked to a device. Catch 22. There is no support!

Reply
Nathan September 27, 2017 at 6:36 am

Excellent write-up Melissa, yet I still find myself on the fence in knowing what is the “best combination” of applications to support my needs; i.e. mPOS paired with best accounting/book keeping SW plug-ins.

Reply
Trevor August 13, 2017 at 8:31 am

Thanks for the helpful and thorough review!

Reply
Brian Powers June 3, 2017 at 3:13 pm

Square’s register function does not have a calculator function, ie. I want to sell 2.5 yards of fabric at 12.99 per yard. I have to do the calculation separately then enter it. Paypal allows me to do the calculation in the register. Is there any workaround to the Square register to allow me to do this? Customer support for the last 1 1/2 years has said, “this is a good idea, and we’ll look at it,” and of course, they haven’t.

Reply

Melissa Johnson June 12, 2017 at 2:11 pm

Hi, Brian!

I’ve got a couple of suggestions. This is a topic that’s actually come up in Square’s community seller forum, and something other users suggested is price points: you can pre-program the costs for particular lengths (1/8, 1/4, 1/2, 1) and then just plug in the quantities until you get the right measurement.

https://www.sellercommunity.com/t5/Using-Square/I-sell-fabric-is-there-a-way-after-scanning-bolt-to-choose-1-2/m-p/13158

Square also has variable price points — which might work if you’re looking to keep sales records and don’t mind plugging in the cost manually still.

https://squareup.com/help/us/en/article/5328-item-variants-or-price-points

I hope that helps! IT would be nice to see Square add pricing by weight or yard in the future though, for certain.

Reply
Courtney Hulsey May 30, 2017 at 10:36 am

I’ve been using paypal for several months and was really happy until PayPal started holding over $500 in “Rolling Reserve.” My business is small, and new. $500, right now, can make or break a month for me. Does the Square do anything like that: hold your money, that clients have already paid, in a reserve for 30, 60, or 90 days?

Reply

Jessica Dinsmore June 19, 2017 at 11:12 am

Hi Courtney,
You might want to check out the “Account stability issues/funding holds” section in our review of Square. Unfortunately Square has been known to put holds on funds as well. If you want to shop around, we have compared a handful of top rated mobile payment companies here with links to each of their reviews for further reading.

Reply
Charlie March 15, 2017 at 7:16 pm

I have the card reader from square and never got the one from paypal however is like to go through paypal. Can I use the square reader with the paypal app?

Reply

Chloe Bahal March 16, 2017 at 10:56 am

Hi Charlie,

Unfortunately the card readers are not interchangeable, so you won’t be able to use the Square reader with Paypal Here.

Reply
melissa February 7, 2017 at 7:21 am

Up until today I’ve been very happy with Square. I use Square for on-site purchases when customers come to my studio and also for custom orders, I send out a Square invoice. My website uses PayPal and I have never had an issue. My biggest frustration with Square was this morning when my password didn’t work – the same password that I’ve had for three years. I finally requested a reset and the verification code they sent didn’t work. And yes, I began to freak out because there is literally NO WAY to contact Square if you can’t access your account. They require that you ‘log in’ to contact them – well how do you log in if your password isn’t working??? The fact that Square’s customer service can’t be accessed if your account goes down is just plain bad business. I spent most of the morning trying to resolve this and finally after the third verification code I was able to access my account. But this has caused me serious concern over continuing to use Square.

Reply
IVy January 29, 2017 at 9:01 pm

I just signed up for Square, im still hesitating with Square and paypal.

When I received Square payment does it go directly to my bank account?

For Paypal. If I invoice my clients I can accumulate it thru paypal and transfer the balance to my bank account?

Reply

Chloe Bahal February 1, 2017 at 10:51 am

Hi Ivy,

Great questions. Yes, when you sign up with Square, you will have the opportunity to sync your bank account. For PayPal, yes, you can transfer the balance to your bank account once your clients pay you. I hope this helps.

Reply
Michael Keller December 30, 2016 at 4:03 pm

Hey so, with “square,” am I able to capture payment remotely? I’m working in e-commerce, and can go door to door for my marketing services today, but I would like to be able to live anywhere in the world and travel, so is it possible to type in payment through square, if they send their information?

Reply

Chloe Bahal January 9, 2017 at 3:47 pm

Hi Michael,

Yes, you will be able to accept card-not-present transactions but the transaction fee is going to be higher. I hope this helps and if you have further questions please let me know.

Reply
Kim December 16, 2016 at 10:01 am

I was told that customers cannot securely key in their own credit card information using Square. I want to be able to email my customers an invoice and allow them to pay online….and then receive an email when the payment has been made. This can be done using PayPal but can it be done using Square?

Reply

Chloe Bahal December 16, 2016 at 2:48 pm

Hi Kim,

You can send invoices with Square. Here is more information on how to do that. I hope this helps and if you have further questions please let me know.

Reply
Jorge O December 8, 2016 at 6:33 pm

After what I just went through in the last couple of days with Pay Pal I will forever discourage people to get PayPal and go with square. I run my own PC repair/support business…I was approved, having already been with PayPal almost ten years I thought it the best way to go…well listen up…. My first three transactions were with typing in the credit card, since I usually work from home, and of course, their cc reader hadn’t arrived… What was that for???!! , after your first $500 PayPal actually holds the amount for 30 days or more. I called the representative and I was like “well I’ve had PayPal for years so what’s the problem” they proceeded to tell me “that’s how it works until you develop better selling habits??” I run a computer help and repair, where I remote into my clients servers, or PCs and fix the problem, so accepting a credit card payment over the phone shouldn’t be a biggy?? Right?? Wring! So basically I did two days or about $1,500 worth of of work, they gave me the first $500 and the other $1,000 is in there or in my pending balance for the next 30 days, just because I typed in the credit card. Mind you I sent them the receipts for the transactions. This is incredible, and a joke. I think it’s horrible 30 days?? This day and age maybe 2 or 3 days for it to clear, I can even do seven for it to clear with the bank but really 30 days???smfh Square took me through a two day process and after sending them my ID and a copy of my receipts everything went smoothly. It goes into my bank account after a day or so, or I can choose to have it immediately sent to my account for a 1% fee. The choice is clear. Hope you don’t babe l make same mistake.

Reply

Keira May 30, 2017 at 5:12 am

I just went through the same thing Jorge, and was looking for feedback about switching from PayPal to Square. Does anyone know if Square does the same thing? I had no idea PayPal would hold my funds for 30 days from a $500 transaction. The other issue I’ve had with PayPal, that I’m hoping Square doesn’t do, is the ONE time I did the manual key in, it held my funds then too.

Reply

Melissa Johnson June 12, 2017 at 2:34 pm

Keira, you’re very likely to see similar behavior from Square. They are both third-party processing services, meaning that instead of you having your own unique merchant account (which is what traditional processors used), all accounts are lumped (or aggregated) into one large account shared by everyone.

On the plus side, it means you don’t have to do much to create an account and start processing. However, because the fraud/underwriting departments don’t do much research or assessment if you or your business model, they’re a lot more finicky about holding funds for transactions. We unfortunately don’t have any information about exactly what criteria either company uses to identify problematic transactions, but manually entering large transactions is usually enough to create a red flag. Likewise, sudden large transactions can raise suspicions — particularly when you’ve got very little processing history or you’ve only processed small transactions until that point.

Depending on what industry you work in, sometimes it’s better to get a high-risk merchant account. And no matter what industry, use invoices or the virtual terminal features instead of keying transactions into the mPOS app if you can.

Hope this helps!

Reply
Ana Castillo November 28, 2016 at 1:05 am

Excellent review for Square vs. Paypal! One thing u left out. U didn’t explain if the device used such as the little square reader can be used for either or. I’m looking to purchase a physical square reader but if I use the app for PayPal will it still work even if I’m using the square device and the app. Is there such a thing?

Reply
deanna November 14, 2016 at 10:32 am

found your article, thanks for the info. however i don’t know when this changed but the paypal reader is no longer free. The reader is 14.99 and they also have a chip card reader for a whopping 149.00

Reply
Mark November 10, 2016 at 12:20 pm

NOT happy with PayPal. If I sell over $500.00 in a given week, they hold my funds for 30 days. I called and they said they couldn’t do anything about it. Has anyone else had an issue with this? I’m thinking of changing to Square.

Reply
David September 15, 2016 at 7:04 am

I have used Paypal for years now and have been fairly happy with them until recently. Paypal does have easy to reach customer service which is nice but the problem is the person your reaching isn’t much help. The Paypal staff seems to be very clueless and confused about their own pollicies. With my experience with Paypal I’ve learned its more of a company for Buyers not Sellers. There are many strange policies Paypal go by. For instance just recently I sold an item on Etsy. It was a custom made custom ordered item specificly built just for this customer. On the Etsy listing we quote 3 weeks for delivery. We did our part we built the item, shipped it, and had good comunication with the customer all within the quoted time frame. For some reason at the very last minute as the item was still in transit the customer chose to cancel the item. Which of course we don’t offer cancelations on custom built items. The customer filed a claim on Paypal because they did not want it anymore. When the item arrived the customer refused delivery. By doing so it basicly is like the customer never recieved the item and we never shipped it in the eyes of Paypal. Even though we had proof it was there but customer said they did’nt want it. Because of that refusal to accept the package Paypal sides with the customer and refunds their money. We’re out time to build the item, money for materials, and shipping fee to ship the item…. Now stuck with a custom built sign with a long unusual last name carved into it that we will Never get rid of. Paypal customer service Rep called it a loop hole in their system. I have encountered many strange situations similar to this from Paypal. Now I dont know what Square would do in that situation but I would hope they would not allow a last second cancelation like this to happen to their seller becuase of a loop hole in the system. Paypal just is more of Buyer favored site.

Reply

Cheyanne September 17, 2016 at 10:38 am

David,

I could not agree with you more. A customer of mine also filed a chargeback under the false claim that he never authorized my company to charge his card. I sent the proof to PayPal as requested. (Email correspondence between the client and I who give his authorization and permission) The representative at PayPal informed me that I had nothing to worry about because I had the correct documents as proof. About 3 days ago, I saw the money withdrawn from my PayPal balance! When I called customer service they informed me that the client’s bank decided to issue him a refund so they had to deduct the money from me.

I was so angry because I have to suffer for this. Even though I provided all documents requested – PayPal refused to cover my loss. They don’t care about small businesses! It’s such a shame that I’ve given them so much money to be treated like this! Not to mention they even threw on a $20 chargeback fee on my account as well.

I have moved to Sqaure. I do hope it will be better with this Merchant.

Reply
Lidia Kenig-Scher July 7, 2016 at 7:15 pm

Indeed a great article. I have been using Paypal for years, and I find the company easy to use and available on the phone when needed. My only complaint is actually their card readers. The little triangle stinks! I have to swipe several times some times, which is useless. I usually bring 2 or 3 to my sales. I’ve seen people use the square reader and it seems like a breeze. The delay in depositing is not so good, but I plan for it.

Reply
Alex June 22, 2016 at 3:31 pm

I have been using PayPal Here for several months and wanted to switch to Square for a more robust POS. I called to sign up with Square and when I said my average transaction would be less than $10, they said transaction fees would be 2.75% + $0.15 per transaction. Is this the same for every quick-serv merchant that has smaller transactions?

Reply

Melissa Johnson June 22, 2016 at 3:38 pm

Hi, Alex!

Unfortunately, yes. as far as mobile/pay-as-you-go options are concerned, PayPal is the only one that offers a micro-transaction pricing option. 2.7%-2.9% is pretty much standard across the board. A few places might have marginally lower rates (check out Intuit GoPayment or Spark Pay, for example) but they aren’t as robust as far as the app goes.

Reply

Alex June 22, 2016 at 5:44 pm

Thanks for the prompt reply. Square’s biggest draw is that 2.75% flat fee and I can’t find anywhere that outlines the additional .15 per transaction other than what the sales rep said. If you sign up online do they freeze your account or change pricing once they see what your sales transactions are?

Reply
Megan Erickson June 9, 2016 at 12:03 pm

My mom is going to start a website and Facebook page for her crafts. She sells homemade crafts (such as these cute trendy banners for weddings, showers, parties, home decor, etc.) mostly to local people and meets them and they pay with cash. However, she is looking to expand her business to having it online and having people purchase her products with a debit/credit card. She wants to know which is most safe for her to use? Thanks, if you can help!

Reply

Chloe Bahal June 15, 2016 at 2:25 pm

Hi Megan,

I would recommend taking a look at Square.

Reply
Denise Smith June 4, 2016 at 2:29 pm

I’ve used PayPal for years and have recommended it to several entrepreneurs. Paypal does have a debit card which , merchants can use to access money immediately. The card is accepted by most companies that accept Mastercard, although I have run across some companies who don’t accept it. However I have now decided to use square for two reasons. Reason one the new Emv reader and lower cost, reason two direct deposit to my bank. Since I haven’t used square long I can’t say whether I prefer it or not.But for right now I’m going to continue to have paypal on my website and use square for in person sales.

Reply
Sharon Bennett March 8, 2016 at 9:29 am

With Square can customers purchase online from my website?

Reply

Chloe Bahal March 14, 2016 at 4:53 pm

Hi Sharon,
Yes, your customers should be able to purchase online. Here is more information on how you can integrate online purchasing with Square.

Reply

Teresa May 28, 2016 at 4:46 pm

Not sure if you mentioned it, but I have the PayPal Here with the (free) debit card, and not only is their swipe rat a tiny bit lower than square’s, but they give you 1% back on what you spend each month, too. 🙂 So, in reality, your swipe rate lowers.

Reply
Billy Bob February 18, 2016 at 8:15 pm

Only Paypal has a Windows Phone app (as of early 2016). Yes, some of us still use Windows Phones. I don’t want to carry a separate phone just to swipe credit cards.

If Square had a Windows Phone app I would use them over Paypal. I don’t like having to “manually” transfer funds from Paypal to my bank. (Square deposits directly into my bank automatically). But no Windows Phone app. Nothing is ever perfect, is it?

Reply

Teresa May 28, 2016 at 4:48 pm

I’m pretty sure you can link your PayPal account to your bank account and/or debit… Although, the easiest thing to do is just have PayPal send you a debit card. It is definitely worth it. 😉

Reply
Perry Strength February 17, 2016 at 3:15 pm

What about a security comparison? Square boast PCI Compliance, whereas PayPal Here is silent on the issue.

Reply
Shane January 25, 2016 at 8:22 am

I will be moving to square. Two big points with square is the ability to track inventory with their system and the automatic transfer to your bank account. I am sure their customer support will become better as more people start using them.

Reply
Lucine December 29, 2015 at 11:49 am

Thank you so much for the comparison. It’s very helpful.

Reply
cecilia December 6, 2015 at 11:17 pm

Thank you for sharing the insight! I was just wondering which credit card reader to get, to get ready for my upcoming sales events at major dance studios! The last thing I want is hearing potential customers saying ‘ oops I don’t have any cash’, and watching them walk away…
Personally I think that, if you’re just starting out, have a small transaction volume, then you really can’t lose choosing one over another.

Reply
katie November 21, 2015 at 2:57 am

Great article. Very helpful. So if I’m reading it write; the only real downside to Paypal is the $25 chargeback fee.

Reply
John November 17, 2015 at 9:19 pm

I’ve been using PayPal for almost 10 years, and frankly I’m delighted to move to Square. PayPal is painful to deal with. They withhold funds if the wind changes direction, and are quick to take take funds from your account. The biggest drawback that hasn’t even been mentioned in this review is that PayPal is effectively its own bank. If you want to use your funds, you might have to move them to your bank, which takes up to 4 days. Square deposits money directly to your bank account, which I find way more convenient.

I’m thrilled to have a realistic contract-free alternative to PayPal!

Reply
Lois November 15, 2015 at 1:01 am

This was a great article. I’m just starting my first retail business and am trying to figure out which way to go.

Reply
Holly Le September 24, 2015 at 12:19 am

This is a great article and it helped me narrow down my decision of which credit card reader to use for my organic bodycare biz, small biz since we just started a couple months ago.! Thank you for posting 🙂

Reply

Amad Ebrahimi September 25, 2015 at 6:03 am

Anytime Holly! Glad to help. 🙂

Reply